MARCOS TOWNSEND, GAZETTE
/ David Landry, found dead on the kitchen floor of his
Plateau Mont Royal apartment, had been taking Wellbutrin
after quitting smoking. Friends said the pills made his
heart race.
|
His
name was David Landry, he was 26, and he was trying to quit
smoking. But in the end it was his life, not just his habit,
that got snuffed out.
Did his anti-smoking medication kill him?
His friends in Montreal and his family back home in
Moncton, N.B., believe so, and a Quebec coroner is
investigating the suspected link, adding to a long list of
similar cases being probed worldwide.
Landry was found dead on the kitchen floor of his Plateau
Mont Royal apartment two weeks ago, a sponge by his side and a
bottle of little purple pills in the adjacent bathroom.
The pills were bupropion hydrochloride. Taken by more than
one million Canadians and subsidized in Quebec under the
province's drug-insurance plan, it's a stimulant used to treat
depression or to help people stop smoking.
It's sold under a couple of names: Wellbutrin and Zyban.
Smokers pop two pills a day for three months, hoping
they'll be one of the lucky one in three for whom the drug
cuts the body's craving for nicotine, breaking the habit.
Landry, a tattooed astrology buff and painter who ate
vegetarian and made his living in telemarketing, had been on
the medication for 10 days, and had doubled the dosage as
prescribed after the first week.
According to friends, the pills had made his heart race and
his mood slightly euphoric. But figuring those were just
normal side-effects of the drug, and adamant that he would
quit smoking, he kept taking it.
"There was nothing that really triggered any alarm in him
or in us, his friends," said hairdresser Jenn Griffin, 24,
whose family doctor prescribed Landry his Wellbutrin.
"It was just the usual side-effects."
Griffin found Landry's body in his Gilford St. flat the
night of Feb. 11. Stunned, searching for an explanation, she
leaped to the conclusion that the pills in the bathroom
cupboard had been her friend's downfall.
"There was no other explanation. He was healthy, he had no
history of heart problems, just a bit of depression in his
family. From the moment I found him, I knew it was the
(Wellbutrin) that killed him."
But the coroner won't yet go that far.
"It's surprising when a young man of 26 dies suddenly and
non-violently," said Francois Houle, of the coroner's office.
"But until the police and coroner's investigations are
complete, it's too early to say" whether the pills were the
cause, he added.
The drug's manufacturer, the pharmaceutical giant
GlaxoSmithKline, denies any suggestion its product can cause
death.
"There has not been a direct link between Zyban and
fatalities - it's unproven," said Carlo Mastrangelo, spokesman
at Glaxo's Canadian headquarters in Mississauga, Ont.
But there is no denying the controversy.
In the three years since it started being marketed
internationally as an aid to stop smoking, bupropion has been
suspected as the cause of hundreds of cases of unwanted
side-effects and even death.
In several Western countries, including Canada, health
authorities are monitoring so-called "adverse events"
associated with the drug.
Among the more severe side-effects reported have been
seizures, strokes, heart attacks, psychotic episodes and
depression. In Britain, Australia and Canada, Zyban has been
suspected in at least 22 deaths.
"There's a kind of panic right now about Zyban," said
Marcel Boulanger, a retired anesthetist who runs the Montreal
Heart Institute's smoking-cessation program.
"It's true the drug has a number of undesirable effects;
it's not a harmless drug," said Boulanger, an occasional paid
consultant to Glaxo who has taught medical students how to
prescribe it.
But put in perspective, he added, the risk is very low.
More than one million Canadians have taken the drug since it
came on the market in mid-1998, but at last count only 407
Zyban users and 67 Wellbutrin users have had any adverse
reaction.
Health Canada statistics compiled in January 2000 show that
256 of those Zyban reactions were serious. They included three
people who died of heart attacks; two had a history of heart
disease.
Because smokers are at risk of a lot of deadly and
debilitating things anyway, and because quitting smoking
itself can be stressful, it's hard to pinpoint Zyban as
aggravating their condition - least of all causing death.
Landry was a case in point.
Like many in his circle in the bohemian Plateau, he liked
to go to bars, drink, smoke a bit of pot, his friends say. And
before he tried to quit, he was a half-a-pack-a-day cigarette
smoker.
While on his medication, however, he cleaned up his act. A
few days before he died, for example, he declined an
invitation from friends to go out drinking. He knew alcohol
and bupropion don't mix.
The drug's labeling carries other warnings: it can cause
seizures in one patient per 1,000 and has milder side-effects,
like insomnia, dry mouth and skin rashes. Those are the ones
Glaxo emphasizes on its packaging.
But now concerns over a link to fatal heart attacks and
mental problems have put the company on the defensive, as it
fends off a backlash by doctors and anti-smoking advocates who
once hailed the drug.
In Australia, where the drug went on sale last November,
the Melbourne newspaper the Age said last week there have been
68 official reports of suspected adverse events, including 24
reports of psychological disturbances and one death - a
patient who suffered a massive lung clot about three days
after stopping Zyban.
Psychiatrists and family doctors warned last Monday that
the drug could trigger a psychotic episode in schizophrenics
and should be used with caution. In England, the national
Department of Health is also monitoring Zyban after receiving
notification of 18 deaths possibly associated with the drug.
Zyban has been approved for smoking-cessation in Canada,
the United States, Australia, New Zealand and most European
countries. Glaxo estimates that more than 15 million people
worldwide have taken Zyban since it was first marketed in
1997. Last year in Canada, pharmacists filled out 1.2 million
prescriptions for Zyban and Wellbutrin, totaling $70 million
in retail sales, the drug statistics firm IMS Health Canada
estimates.
Landry was one of those who tried it. His bottle of
Wellbutrin cost him $60. Until the coroner's report, it will
be unclear whether he ultimately paid a much higher price: his
life.
"The take-home message for people thinking of taking a new
medication is to always be on guard," said Mark Palayew, a
respirologist at Jewish General Hospital. "Always beware and
make sure you don't fit the profile of someone who shouldn't
be taking that drug."
- GlaxoSmithKline's corporate Web site for Zyban is
www.zyban.com/
- For details of problems with Zyban reported in Canada,
consult Health Canada's Adverse Drug Reaction Newsletter of
January 2000. It's on the Web at
www.hc-sc.gc.ca/hpb-dgps/therapeut/zfiles/english/publicat/adrv10n1_e.html