OUISVILLE, Ky. - The L-Marc Research clinic
stands at the geographic center of an American epidemic, where the
meat-and-potatoes Midwest meets the chicken-fried South, and just
across the street from a McDonald's.
The clinic is a leading recruitment post in the drug industry's
multibillion-dollar war on fat. Desperate to be thin, overweight
people eagerly respond to L-Marc's local newspaper ads for
volunteers to test experimental weight-loss drugs. For each trial,
the clinic is forced to turn away dozens of volunteers.
"I've had people crying on the phone," said Heather Hausberger,
the dietitian who screens applicants. "They've tried everything.
Nothing seems to work. A lot of people are looking for the quick
fix, the magic pill."
Many drug makers, too, are seeking that magic pill. From
pharmaceutical giants to tiny start-ups, the industry is spending
billions of dollars developing obesity drugs. An estimated 200
possibilities are now in the research pipeline or under test among
patients at dozens of clinics like L-Marc, according to MedMarket
Diligence, a health care research firm.
Some drug makers say they are tackling fat in response to public
health warnings of a national obesity epidemic - one that has been
linked to diabetes, heart disease and other conditions and now
accounts for more than $100 billion of the United States' $1.8
trillion annual medical bill. The obese are defined as those with a
so-called body mass index of 30 or more. By that measure, obese
people now make up one-third of the adult population.
But many drug industry analysts see a potentially even bigger
market if such a drug also catches on among the more than 60 percent
of adults in this country who are statistically overweight, those
with a body mass index of 25 or more. Many experts also see a
likelihood - some would say danger - that such a drug might appeal
to millions who are by no means fat but would like to drop a few
pounds.
"Everybody is just foaming at the mouth to make money" from
obesity drugs, said Dr. Donna Ryan, an obesity researcher affiliated
with Louisiana State University, which has received millions of
dollars in government and drug-industry grants.
Industry forecasters say that an effective weight-loss drug could
have annual sales far surpassing the current best-selling drug, the
cholesterol treatment Lipitor, which reached $12 billion last year,
especially now that Medicare says it will pay for "effective"
obesity treatments.
Some experts caution that the complex variables of culture,
environment, genetics and lifestyle that contribute to obesity may
defy a mass-market solution. "One pill fits all doesn't seem like an
outcome we'll be seeing on the horizon anytime soon," said Dr. Julie
Gerberding, the physician who directs the federal Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention.
But most of the biggest drug makers feel financially compelled to
stay in the hunt. As it becomes more and more difficult to identify
blockbusters, many companies see few other prospective best sellers
in their research pipelines.
One of the most closely watched weight-loss treatments in
late-stage clinical trials is Acomplia, made by Sanofi-Aventis,
based in Paris. It works by blocking the same pleasure receptor in
the brain that responds to the effects of marijuana. Test patients
who took the drug for two years lost an average of 16 pounds, the
company said. Sanofi-Aventis is expected to seek Food and Drug
Administration approval for Acomplia by this summer.
Other approaches include a weight-loss nasal spray that a
biotechnology company, Nastech Pharmaceutical, is testing in
partnership with Merck.
The spray contains a synthetic version of a human protein that
signals a person's brain to stop eating when food reaches the
intestines.
"Cures" for fat, of course, have long been staples of the herbal
supplement and over-the-counter medicine businesses, as well as the
diet industry. Amphetamines were widely used as diet pills in the
1950's and 1960's, before physicians recognized their addictive
effects. More recently, amphetamine-like substances have been sold
as over-the-counter treatments.
And the fen-phen prescription drug combination was popular during
the mid-1990's, until it was found to damage patients' hearts.
Indeed, the $21 billion that Wyeth
estimates it will cost to settle legal claims related to fen-phen
serves as a cautionary tale for any drug maker tempted to put a fat
pill onto the mass market.
So might the reaction against another diet drug already on the
market, Meridia, made by Abbott
Laboratories, which has been linked to elevated blood pressure.
Public Citizen, the consumer group, has asked for its withdrawal and
an F.D.A. official listed it among five drugs that the agency needs
to review.