In areas of smoggy air, children playing sports are three times
more likely to develop asthma than those who don't actively
exercise, while in regions of cleaner air, there is no such link
between asthma and exercise, according to a study released
yesterday.
The findings by researchers at the University of Southern
California are the strongest evidence yet that smog doesn't only
bring on asthma attacks among those who already have it, but also
may cause asthma in youngsters.
Asthma is the most common childhood disease, and has increased in
the last 20 years to some 9 million children. Earlier findings
showed that air pollution contributed to school absenteeism and also
impaired a child's growing lungs.
The study found that children who participated in three or more
sports such as basketball, football, soccer and softball in
communities with high concentrations of ground-level ozone, the main
ingredient in smog, were found to have asthma at a rate more than
three times higher than children who weren't exercising in the bad
air. Sports had no effect on new diagnoses of asthma in areas of
relatively clean air.
The results will be published tomorrow in the Lancet, a British
medical journal.
The findings are the latest to be released in a 10-year study
financed mainly by the California Air Resources Board to examine
links between air pollution and children's health. The air board,
part of the state Environmental Protection Agency, regulates air
quality.
"We've known for some time that smog can trigger attacks in
asthmatics. This study has shown that ozone can cause asthma as
well," said Alan C. Lloyd, chairman of the state Air Resources
Board.
Between 1993 and 1998, researchers followed 3,535 children from
schools in 12 Southern California towns -- six with higher than
average ozone levels and and six with lower than average levels.
They looked at children without histories of asthma from the fourth,
seventh and 10th grades, and monitored their activities, including
sports. Once a year they asked whether a doctor had given them any
new diagnoses for disease.
The researchers also measured air pollution, which was produced
mainly by vehicles, and tracked the hourly levels of ozone,
particles of dust and smoke, nitrogen dioxide and acid.
Over five years, they found that asthma had been diagnosed in 264
children. Overall, children playing active sports in areas of the
highest ozone were most likely to develop the disease. Asthma
increased with the amount of team sports that the children played.
Researchers said their analysis ruled out the possibility that
the children had asthma all along but just hadn't been diagnosed
until their intense participation in team sports.
"Somewhat to our surprise, in low-ozone communities, we found no
increased risk of asthma in children who played team sports," said
Dr. Rob McConnell, associate professor of preventive medicine at the
Keck School of Medicine of the University of Southern California and
lead author of the study.
"Exercise-induced asthma is well known. So it's not surprising to
see an increase in asthma among children who play lots of team
sports. But people haven't looked at the combination of sports and
air pollution. The air pollution piece is interesting because we see
no effect of sports in the low- ozone communities."
Also, the researchers couldn't explain the increase in asthma by
other factors such as socioeconomic status, family history of asthma
or allergy, or housing conditions, McConnell said.
The study is significant nationally because other regions --
Houston, Denver, Phoenix and Chicago -- have ozone levels that would
probably produce the same health results, said Alan Lloyd, chairman
of the state Air Resources Board.
Although the Bay Area has violated ozone standards seven times
over the past three years, its average concentrations don't place it
among the nation's worst regions.
"We've made significant progress in reducing air pollution, but
we haven't attained health-based air quality standards," Lloyd said
of the state's air. "We have to continue more stringently to make
sure we attain those standards."
Despite the findings, parents should encourage children to
exercise because of the great health benefits, he said. "But you
want to keep attuned to the health advisories, and modify outdoor
activity. If there's a high pollution level, it would be unwise to
go out and exercise vigorously."
E-mail Jane Kay at jkay@sfchronicle.com.
|