Apr 12, 2007 6:51 am
US/Mountain
Adams Co. Judge Rules Smoking Ban Unconstitutional
Arturo
Santiago
Reporting
(CBS4/AP) BRIGHTON, Colo. The status of the statewide smoking
ban is unclear after an Adams County district judge declared the law
unconstitutional. One legal expert told CBS4 the ruling applies only in Adams
County, although other courts can use it as guidance.
District Judge
Robert Doyle said the ban is unconstitutional because it exempts cigar bars.
Attorneys for the Oasis bar in Adams County challenged the law in court after
the business was cited for allowing people smoke inside.
"There's really
no reason to make a differentiation between a smoking bar, a regular bar, a
smoking lounge and cigar bars," said Michael Martin, the lawyer for
Oasis.
Adams County District Attorney Don Quick plans to appeal the
ruling. Quick said the Colorado Supreme Court may have to weigh in because of
this ruling and others.
Last year, a federal judge said the Legislature
had the right to decide where smoking could be prohibited. But a judge in
Durango ruled that a bar owner was exempt from the law because he sold enough
tobacco products to qualify for an exemption.
Democratic state Sen. Betty
Boyd of Lakewood introduced a bill Wednesday to eliminate the cigar bar
exemption. That would leave Denver International Airport's smoking lounges as
the only public place in Colorado where smoking is allowed.
(© 2007 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report. )

Video